Ingredients:
- 9 Yukon Gold* or Red Potatoes (both of these have better flavor than Russets). Size: Russet-sized
- 8 oz block of cream cheese (low fat is fine, if you prefer), roughly cut into 1-2" pieces
- Stick of butter (all butter mentioned in these recipes is unsalted - I never buy salted butter
- Milk (Oat milk worked great)
- 1 cup or so of sliced green onions, chives, or combination
- Salt and Pepper
*NOTE: If the potatoes are smaller, then eyeball it or fill a medium sized pan about half full of cut potatoes (for 4 people) <-- Used 9 large potatoes from Sprouts for 6 people at Thanksgiving 2021, which was more than twice as much that was eaten given there were other sides. It overfilled an entire 14-cup container.
Directions:
- Cut the potatoes in about 1 inch pieces - these will boil faster. I don't peel mine, but you could if you wanted to. I like the peels on, and it's a lot less work.
- Place potatoes in a pot and fill with just enough water to cover them (or about a 1/4 inch over the top of the potatoes
- Boil for about 20 to 30 minutes, depending on the size of your cut potatoes. You can test them with a fork, or taste them to see if they are done - a fork should easily stab into them
- Drain potatoes and place back into the pan - turn your burner down to low/warm (or off)
- Add the cream cheese. For more people, feel free to add more - or add as much as you want to taste
- Add stick of butter
- Start to mash the potatoes with the butter and cream cheese. I use a hand masher because I like our potatoes lumpy
- Add milk as you need it - start with maybe a quarter cup and go up from there, depending on how creamy/thick or thin you want your texture to be. I leave mine a little lumpy/chunky
- Continue to mash, add salt and pepper, more cream cheese, milk and/or butter if you want, stir, and taste the potatoes until you achieve the taste/consistency you want
- Add the sliced green onions and stir them into the potatoes (if you want) - or you can leave them on the side for people to add as they like
- You can totally play with this recipe. You could use sour cream instead of cream cheese, you can mix in shredded cheddar and bacon too!